Tips for Choosing Your Team Captain

A team captain isn't just someone who wears the armband or wins the coin toss — they are the heart of the team. Whether you're coaching a youth soccer team, managing a high school football team, or playing in an adult league, choosing the right captain can shape the culture, performance, and spirit of your group. Here are key tips to help you choose the best team captain for your squad.

Look for Strong Communicators

A great captain must communicate clearly and respectfully—with teammates, coaches, and even referees. They should feel at ease when giving encouragement and constructive feedback.

Tip: Observe how potential captains communicate with others during practices and games. Do they uplift or criticize?

Pick Someone with Game Intelligence

Captains don’t need to be the top scorers, but they must understand the game. Look for someone who reads the field well, remains composed under pressure, and can assist in guiding the team during tight moments.

Bonus: Game IQ frequently results in smarter decisions regarding strategy and leadership.

Choose a Role Model On and Off the Field

The captain sets the tone for the entire team. They should model sportsmanship, discipline, and effort—whether it’s showing up early to practice or keeping their cool in tough matches.

Watch for: Consistency in attitude and effort, not just big moments.

Prioritize Work Ethic and Commitment

Sometimes, the hardest-working player isn’t the flashiest — but their commitment inspires others. A captain with a strong work ethic motivates the team by example, especially during tough times.

Tip: Look for individuals who give their all, even during drills or off-the-bench moments.

👫 Consider Team Chemistry

A great captain isn’t just respected by the coach; they are respected by their peers. Choose someone who connects with the team, listens attentively, and fosters unity.

How to gauge this: Ask teammates who they naturally look to for support or guidance.

Match Leadership Style to Team Needs

Some teams require a vocal leader to energize everyone. Others benefit from a calm presence that maintains the group’s stability. Select a captain whose style aligns with your team’s dynamics and objectives.

Tip: Don’t just default to the most outgoing player — consider what the team truly needs.

Don’t Be Afraid to Involve the Team

Sometimes, the best insights come from within. Consider organizing a team vote, implementing a private nomination process, or engaging in open discussions with assistant coaches or veteran players.

But: Always reserve the final decision to ensure it aligns with the long-term team goals.

The right team captain can uplift a group, build lasting trust, and transform potential into performance. Take your time, look beyond mere skill, and select someone who leads by example, earns respect, and brings people together. Because in the end, leadership isn't just about being the loudest — it's about being the one others willingly follow.

At PTJ Shoes, we strive to empower players of all levels to embrace their individuality and play with confidence. We take pride in being a brand founded on passion, driven by family values, and designed for the next generation of game-changers.

Check out our elite collection of designer soccer cleats here.